Introduction: The Dilemma of Police Pursuits
Governor Gavin Newsom has pushed Oakland to expand its police department’s ability to pursue suspects, responding to public demand for tougher crime policies. He noted that voters have recently expressed a clear desire for stronger crime measures. However, a recent high-speed chase in San Francisco that resulted in a crash, sending six people, including a child, to the hospital, serves as a stark reminder of the dangers of police pursuits.
The Dangers of High-Speed Chases
Studies indicate that at least 30% of police vehicle chases lead to collisions, with nearly 20% resulting in injuries or fatalities. As cities across the country grapple with the trade-offs between law enforcement goals and public safety, experts warn that the risks posed by these pursuits are significant.
Geoffrey Alpert, a criminology professor and expert on police chases, helped create Oakland’s pursuit policy, which allows chases only if the suspect is believed to be armed or involved in a violent crime. He argues that loosening these policies would put public health at risk. “If you start chasing for minor offenses, you’re signing death warrants,” Alpert warned. “It’s extremely dangerous.”
The Push for Stricter Policies
The recent spike in traffic-related deaths has led many cities to reassess their pursuit policies. New York City, for example, has banned chases for traffic violations and low-level offenses, reserving police pursuits for felonies or violent misdemeanors. Similarly, Houston restricted chases in 2023 after a rise in injuries and fatalities linked to police pursuits.
In 2023, the Police Executive Research Forum recommended that pursuits be allowed only when a violent crime has occurred and the suspect is an imminent threat. Executive Director Chuck Wexler emphasized, “You can get a suspect another day, but you can’t get a life back.”
The Cost of Police Pursuits in California
In California, nearly 12,000 police pursuits were reported in 2022, leading to more than 400 injuries to bystanders. Of the 34 fatalities, five were uninvolved bystanders. Nationwide, over 500 people were killed in police chases in 2020, an increase from previous years.
However, federal data often underrepresents the true number of deaths. A report by the San Francisco Chronicle revealed that hundreds of fatalities linked to police pursuits were not recorded in federal databases, bringing the total number of deaths from 2017 to 2021 to over 3,000.
Balancing Public Safety and Crime Control
Criminologist Alexis Piquero stresses the importance of careful consideration when formulating pursuit policies. While acknowledging the dangers of police chases, particularly with high speeds and heavy pedestrian traffic, Piquero suggests that police should be allowed to pursue suspects fleeing minor offenses. He questioned, “What’s the risk-reward calculation? How much danger are we willing to accept?”
Following several deaths in Oakland linked to police pursuits, the city imposed stricter policies in December 2022, including speed limits on chases. These changes led to a significant reduction in pursuits, from 130 in 2022 to 38 in the first half of 2024. However, injuries remained unchanged, and arrests and firearm recoveries decreased.
A Personal Tragedy Sparks Advocacy
For Mark Priano, the issue of police chases is personal. In 2002, his 15-year-old daughter, Kristie, was killed when their car was struck during a police chase in Chico. The officers were pursuing a teenager joyriding in her mother’s car. Priano recalled the tragic incident, saying, “We got T-boned. Never saw it coming.”
In response, Priano and his family advocated for legislation to limit police pursuits to cases where “imminent peril” exists, an effort known as Kristie’s Law. Despite their persistent efforts, the proposed changes were not enacted, and Priano remains frustrated by the lack of safeguards in pursuit policies.
Conclusion: The Ongoing Debate
The debate over police chases in California highlights the challenge of balancing crime prevention with public safety. As some cities push for more lenient pursuit policies, the risk to innocent lives remains high. As communities continue to grapple with this issue, the question remains: How far are we willing to go to enforce law and order at the expense of public safety?
Leave a Reply